{
 "axes": [
  "accountability",
  "affect",
  "care",
  "continuity",
  "creativity",
  "efficiency",
  "fairness",
  "gov",
  "human-vs-ai",
  "jail",
  "privacy",
  "provenance",
  "safety",
  "slot15",
  "sovereignty",
  "swarm",
  "transparency"
 ],
 "content_id": "d677c1fb21808d0ee74214e8fdc343f4e498785da7b8bf34e0fce71bb3a9f358",
 "generated": "2026-08-24T03:27:31Z",
 "leaderboard": [
  {
   "ci": [
    0.691,
    0.753
   ],
   "elo": 1624.7,
   "games": 797,
   "model": "mistral:7b",
   "winrate": 0.723
  },
  {
   "ci": [
    0.658,
    0.718
   ],
   "elo": 1578.1,
   "games": 899,
   "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
   "winrate": 0.689
  },
  {
   "ci": [
    0.69,
    0.751
   ],
   "elo": 1560.6,
   "games": 847,
   "model": "qwen3:4b",
   "winrate": 0.721
  },
  {
   "ci": [
    0.385,
    0.45
   ],
   "elo": 1545.4,
   "games": 887,
   "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
   "winrate": 0.417
  },
  {
   "ci": [
    0.358,
    0.705
   ],
   "elo": 1518.8,
   "games": 28,
   "model": "llama3:8b",
   "winrate": 0.536
  },
  {
   "ci": [
    0.247,
    0.314
   ],
   "elo": 1496.4,
   "games": 691,
   "model": "council-safe:latest",
   "winrate": 0.279
  },
  {
   "ci": [
    0.198,
    0.643
   ],
   "elo": 1481.3,
   "games": 15,
   "model": "qwen3:8b",
   "winrate": 0.4
  },
  {
   "ci": [
    0.279,
    0.649
   ],
   "elo": 1448.8,
   "games": 24,
   "model": "deepseek-r1:7b",
   "winrate": 0.458
  },
  {
   "ci": [
    0.324,
    0.386
   ],
   "elo": 1443.4,
   "games": 905,
   "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
   "winrate": 0.355
  },
  {
   "ci": [
    0.239,
    0.308
   ],
   "elo": 1440.9,
   "games": 654,
   "model": "council-oowm:latest",
   "winrate": 0.272
  },
  {
   "ci": [
    0.399,
    0.552
   ],
   "elo": 1439.2,
   "games": 160,
   "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
   "winrate": 0.475
  },
  {
   "ci": [
    0.321,
    0.455
   ],
   "elo": 1422.3,
   "games": 197,
   "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
   "winrate": 0.386
  }
 ],
 "method": "Bradley-Terry Elo, K=32, value-weighted (per-axis), Wilson 95% CI, style-control credit (length-decided rounds weighted <1). n>=5.",
 "models": 12,
 "per_axis": {
  "accountability": [
   {
    "axis": "accountability",
    "ci": [
     0.424,
     0.873
    ],
    "elo": 1558.6,
    "games": 13,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.692
   },
   {
    "axis": "accountability",
    "ci": [
     0.357,
     0.802
    ],
    "elo": 1517.8,
    "games": 15,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.6
   },
   {
    "axis": "accountability",
    "ci": [
     0.32,
     0.807
    ],
    "elo": 1515.4,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.583
   },
   {
    "axis": "accountability",
    "ci": [
     0.232,
     0.709
    ],
    "elo": 1500.2,
    "games": 13,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.462
   },
   {
    "axis": "accountability",
    "ci": [
     0.254,
     0.746
    ],
    "elo": 1496.7,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "accountability",
    "ci": [
     0.118,
     0.769
    ],
    "elo": 1483.6,
    "games": 5,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.4
   },
   {
    "axis": "accountability",
    "ci": [
     0.158,
     0.75
    ],
    "elo": 1481.8,
    "games": 7,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.429
   },
   {
    "axis": "accountability",
    "ci": [
     0.097,
     0.566
    ],
    "elo": 1444.0,
    "games": 11,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.273
   },
   {
    "axis": "accountability",
    "ci": [
     0.082,
     0.503
    ],
    "elo": 1420.1,
    "games": 13,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.231
   }
  ],
  "affect": [
   {
    "axis": "affect",
    "ci": [
     0.527,
     0.904
    ],
    "elo": 1611.5,
    "games": 17,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.765
   },
   {
    "axis": "affect",
    "ci": [
     0.46,
     0.846
    ],
    "elo": 1585.5,
    "games": 19,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.684
   },
   {
    "axis": "affect",
    "ci": [
     0.237,
     0.763
    ],
    "elo": 1500.3,
    "games": 10,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "affect",
    "ci": [
     0.28,
     0.72
    ],
    "elo": 1495.6,
    "games": 16,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "affect",
    "ci": [
     0.158,
     0.75
    ],
    "elo": 1491.2,
    "games": 7,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.429
   },
   {
    "axis": "affect",
    "ci": [
     0.193,
     0.68
    ],
    "elo": 1472.0,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.417
   },
   {
    "axis": "affect",
    "ci": [
     0.177,
     0.645
    ],
    "elo": 1463.6,
    "games": 13,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.385
   },
   {
    "axis": "affect",
    "ci": [
     0.163,
     0.612
    ],
    "elo": 1460.3,
    "games": 14,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.357
   },
   {
    "axis": "affect",
    "ci": [
     0.163,
     0.612
    ],
    "elo": 1455.9,
    "games": 14,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.357
   }
  ],
  "care": [
   {
    "axis": "care",
    "ci": [
     0.531,
     0.888
    ],
    "elo": 1580.9,
    "games": 20,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.75
   },
   {
    "axis": "care",
    "ci": [
     0.453,
     0.937
    ],
    "elo": 1569.5,
    "games": 9,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.778
   },
   {
    "axis": "care",
    "ci": [
     0.313,
     0.832
    ],
    "elo": 1547.0,
    "games": 10,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.6
   },
   {
    "axis": "care",
    "ci": [
     0.258,
     0.658
    ],
    "elo": 1494.2,
    "games": 20,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.45
   },
   {
    "axis": "care",
    "ci": [
     0.189,
     0.733
    ],
    "elo": 1494.0,
    "games": 9,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.444
   },
   {
    "axis": "care",
    "ci": [
     0.168,
     0.687
    ],
    "elo": 1482.5,
    "games": 10,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.4
   },
   {
    "axis": "care",
    "ci": [
     0.189,
     0.733
    ],
    "elo": 1464.1,
    "games": 9,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.444
   },
   {
    "axis": "care",
    "ci": [
     0.108,
     0.603
    ],
    "elo": 1457.0,
    "games": 10,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.3
   },
   {
    "axis": "care",
    "ci": [
     0.022,
     0.471
    ],
    "elo": 1424.5,
    "games": 8,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.125
   }
  ],
  "continuity": [
   {
    "axis": "continuity",
    "ci": [
     0.907,
     0.975
    ],
    "elo": 1905.5,
    "games": 165,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.952
   },
   {
    "axis": "continuity",
    "ci": [
     0.68,
     0.806
    ],
    "elo": 1621.5,
    "games": 179,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.749
   },
   {
    "axis": "continuity",
    "ci": [
     0.525,
     0.671
    ],
    "elo": 1613.2,
    "games": 170,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.6
   },
   {
    "axis": "continuity",
    "ci": [
     0.405,
     0.551
    ],
    "elo": 1563.6,
    "games": 178,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.478
   },
   {
    "axis": "continuity",
    "ci": [
     0.254,
     0.746
    ],
    "elo": 1466.7,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "continuity",
    "ci": [
     0.036,
     0.624
    ],
    "elo": 1438.8,
    "games": 5,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.2
   },
   {
    "axis": "continuity",
    "ci": [
     0.176,
     0.308
    ],
    "elo": 1383.2,
    "games": 157,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.236
   },
   {
    "axis": "continuity",
    "ci": [
     0.127,
     0.26
    ],
    "elo": 1354.6,
    "games": 130,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.185
   },
   {
    "axis": "continuity",
    "ci": [
     0.097,
     0.216
    ],
    "elo": 1162.4,
    "games": 136,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.147
   }
  ],
  "creativity": [
   {
    "axis": "creativity",
    "ci": [
     0.444,
     0.858
    ],
    "elo": 1562.3,
    "games": 16,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.688
   },
   {
    "axis": "creativity",
    "ci": [
     0.391,
     0.862
    ],
    "elo": 1547.9,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.667
   },
   {
    "axis": "creativity",
    "ci": [
     0.32,
     0.807
    ],
    "elo": 1529.7,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.583
   },
   {
    "axis": "creativity",
    "ci": [
     0.326,
     0.786
    ],
    "elo": 1522.7,
    "games": 14,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.571
   },
   {
    "axis": "creativity",
    "ci": [
     0.313,
     0.832
    ],
    "elo": 1516.7,
    "games": 10,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.6
   },
   {
    "axis": "creativity",
    "ci": [
     0.237,
     0.763
    ],
    "elo": 1505.8,
    "games": 10,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "creativity",
    "ci": [
     0.127,
     0.576
    ],
    "elo": 1441.3,
    "games": 13,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.308
   },
   {
    "axis": "creativity",
    "ci": [
     0.185,
     0.614
    ],
    "elo": 1439.0,
    "games": 16,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.375
   },
   {
    "axis": "creativity",
    "ci": [
     0.133,
     0.531
    ],
    "elo": 1438.7,
    "games": 17,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.294
   }
  ],
  "efficiency": [
   {
    "axis": "efficiency",
    "ci": [
     0.487,
     0.974
    ],
    "elo": 1571.4,
    "games": 7,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.857
   },
   {
    "axis": "efficiency",
    "ci": [
     0.388,
     0.837
    ],
    "elo": 1548.7,
    "games": 14,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.643
   },
   {
    "axis": "efficiency",
    "ci": [
     0.386,
     0.815
    ],
    "elo": 1516.9,
    "games": 16,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.625
   },
   {
    "axis": "efficiency",
    "ci": [
     0.254,
     0.746
    ],
    "elo": 1510.0,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "efficiency",
    "ci": [
     0.237,
     0.763
    ],
    "elo": 1509.9,
    "games": 10,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "efficiency",
    "ci": [
     0.214,
     0.674
    ],
    "elo": 1498.7,
    "games": 14,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.429
   },
   {
    "axis": "efficiency",
    "ci": [
     0.152,
     0.646
    ],
    "elo": 1472.1,
    "games": 11,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.364
   },
   {
    "axis": "efficiency",
    "ci": [
     0.267,
     0.629
    ],
    "elo": 1448.9,
    "games": 25,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.44
   },
   {
    "axis": "efficiency",
    "ci": [
     0.163,
     0.612
    ],
    "elo": 1437.5,
    "games": 14,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.357
   }
  ],
  "fairness": [
   {
    "axis": "fairness",
    "ci": [
     0.46,
     0.846
    ],
    "elo": 1592.8,
    "games": 19,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.684
   },
   {
    "axis": "fairness",
    "ci": [
     0.388,
     0.837
    ],
    "elo": 1538.0,
    "games": 14,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.643
   },
   {
    "axis": "fairness",
    "ci": [
     0.354,
     0.848
    ],
    "elo": 1519.7,
    "games": 11,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.636
   },
   {
    "axis": "fairness",
    "ci": [
     0.254,
     0.746
    ],
    "elo": 1506.3,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "fairness",
    "ci": [
     0.237,
     0.763
    ],
    "elo": 1505.7,
    "games": 10,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "fairness",
    "ci": [
     0.193,
     0.68
    ],
    "elo": 1498.2,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.417
   },
   {
    "axis": "fairness",
    "ci": [
     0.213,
     0.72
    ],
    "elo": 1495.9,
    "games": 11,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.455
   },
   {
    "axis": "fairness",
    "ci": [
     0.246,
     0.663
    ],
    "elo": 1474.7,
    "games": 18,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.444
   },
   {
    "axis": "fairness",
    "ci": [
     0.082,
     0.641
    ],
    "elo": 1460.0,
    "games": 7,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.286
   }
  ],
  "gov": [
   {
    "axis": "gov",
    "ci": [
     0.948,
     0.992
    ],
    "elo": 1975.4,
    "games": 194,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.979
   },
   {
    "axis": "gov",
    "ci": [
     0.525,
     0.661
    ],
    "elo": 1598.1,
    "games": 195,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.595
   },
   {
    "axis": "gov",
    "ci": [
     0.453,
     0.937
    ],
    "elo": 1545.7,
    "games": 9,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.778
   },
   {
    "axis": "gov",
    "ci": [
     0.517,
     0.668
    ],
    "elo": 1532.1,
    "games": 158,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.595
   },
   {
    "axis": "gov",
    "ci": [
     0.451,
     0.588
    ],
    "elo": 1528.0,
    "games": 200,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.52
   },
   {
    "axis": "gov",
    "ci": [
     0.28,
     0.787
    ],
    "elo": 1495.0,
    "games": 11,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.545
   },
   {
    "axis": "gov",
    "ci": [
     0.283,
     0.412
    ],
    "elo": 1394.2,
    "games": 206,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.345
   },
   {
    "axis": "gov",
    "ci": [
     0.095,
     0.207
    ],
    "elo": 1282.2,
    "games": 148,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.142
   },
   {
    "axis": "gov",
    "ci": [
     0.078,
     0.192
    ],
    "elo": 1159.8,
    "games": 129,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.124
   }
  ],
  "human-vs-ai": [
   {
    "axis": "human-vs-ai",
    "ci": [
     0.531,
     0.888
    ],
    "elo": 1600.2,
    "games": 20,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.75
   },
   {
    "axis": "human-vs-ai",
    "ci": [
     0.3,
     0.903
    ],
    "elo": 1531.2,
    "games": 6,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.667
   },
   {
    "axis": "human-vs-ai",
    "ci": [
     0.313,
     0.832
    ],
    "elo": 1525.8,
    "games": 10,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.6
   },
   {
    "axis": "human-vs-ai",
    "ci": [
     0.317,
     0.727
    ],
    "elo": 1509.3,
    "games": 19,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.526
   },
   {
    "axis": "human-vs-ai",
    "ci": [
     0.232,
     0.709
    ],
    "elo": 1505.6,
    "games": 13,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.462
   },
   {
    "axis": "human-vs-ai",
    "ci": [
     0.137,
     0.694
    ],
    "elo": 1479.6,
    "games": 8,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.375
   },
   {
    "axis": "human-vs-ai",
    "ci": [
     0.137,
     0.694
    ],
    "elo": 1470.9,
    "games": 8,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.375
   },
   {
    "axis": "human-vs-ai",
    "ci": [
     0.138,
     0.609
    ],
    "elo": 1449.3,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.333
   },
   {
    "axis": "human-vs-ai",
    "ci": [
     0.117,
     0.546
    ],
    "elo": 1422.3,
    "games": 14,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.286
   }
  ],
  "jail": [
   {
    "axis": "jail",
    "ci": [
     0.453,
     0.937
    ],
    "elo": 1561.0,
    "games": 9,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.778
   },
   {
    "axis": "jail",
    "ci": [
     0.359,
     0.918
    ],
    "elo": 1546.9,
    "games": 7,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.714
   },
   {
    "axis": "jail",
    "ci": [
     0.36,
     0.784
    ],
    "elo": 1525.3,
    "games": 17,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.588
   },
   {
    "axis": "jail",
    "ci": [
     0.291,
     0.768
    ],
    "elo": 1519.8,
    "games": 13,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.538
   },
   {
    "axis": "jail",
    "ci": [
     0.291,
     0.768
    ],
    "elo": 1512.7,
    "games": 13,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.538
   },
   {
    "axis": "jail",
    "ci": [
     0.268,
     0.732
    ],
    "elo": 1495.2,
    "games": 14,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "jail",
    "ci": [
     0.28,
     0.72
    ],
    "elo": 1488.2,
    "games": 16,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "jail",
    "ci": [
     0.177,
     0.645
    ],
    "elo": 1461.3,
    "games": 13,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.385
   },
   {
    "axis": "jail",
    "ci": [
     0.037,
     0.379
    ],
    "elo": 1370.3,
    "games": 15,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.133
   }
  ],
  "privacy": [
   {
    "axis": "privacy",
    "ci": [
     0.468,
     0.911
    ],
    "elo": 1567.1,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.75
   },
   {
    "axis": "privacy",
    "ci": [
     0.355,
     0.823
    ],
    "elo": 1545.2,
    "games": 13,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.615
   },
   {
    "axis": "privacy",
    "ci": [
     0.254,
     0.746
    ],
    "elo": 1502.2,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "privacy",
    "ci": [
     0.215,
     0.785
    ],
    "elo": 1499.9,
    "games": 8,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "privacy",
    "ci": [
     0.215,
     0.785
    ],
    "elo": 1499.4,
    "games": 8,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "privacy",
    "ci": [
     0.158,
     0.75
    ],
    "elo": 1489.3,
    "games": 7,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.429
   },
   {
    "axis": "privacy",
    "ci": [
     0.137,
     0.694
    ],
    "elo": 1476.0,
    "games": 8,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.375
   },
   {
    "axis": "privacy",
    "ci": [
     0.121,
     0.646
    ],
    "elo": 1465.4,
    "games": 9,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.333
   },
   {
    "axis": "privacy",
    "ci": [
     0.152,
     0.646
    ],
    "elo": 1458.4,
    "games": 11,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.364
   }
  ],
  "provenance": [
   {
    "axis": "provenance",
    "ci": [
     0.943,
     0.993
    ],
    "elo": 2008.1,
    "games": 150,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.98
   },
   {
    "axis": "provenance",
    "ci": [
     0.702,
     0.834
    ],
    "elo": 1736.6,
    "games": 151,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.775
   },
   {
    "axis": "provenance",
    "ci": [
     0.579,
     0.729
    ],
    "elo": 1659.3,
    "games": 152,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.658
   },
   {
    "axis": "provenance",
    "ci": [
     0.277,
     0.441
    ],
    "elo": 1307.5,
    "games": 127,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.354
   },
   {
    "axis": "provenance",
    "ci": [
     0.173,
     0.3
    ],
    "elo": 1289.7,
    "games": 165,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.23
   },
   {
    "axis": "provenance",
    "ci": [
     0.176,
     0.301
    ],
    "elo": 1273.1,
    "games": 172,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.233
   },
   {
    "axis": "provenance",
    "ci": [
     0.212,
     0.365
    ],
    "elo": 1225.6,
    "games": 131,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.282
   }
  ],
  "safety": [
   {
    "axis": "safety",
    "ci": [
     0.75,
     0.867
    ],
    "elo": 1826.8,
    "games": 168,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.815
   },
   {
    "axis": "safety",
    "ci": [
     0.857,
     0.94
    ],
    "elo": 1785.4,
    "games": 192,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.906
   },
   {
    "axis": "safety",
    "ci": [
     0.568,
     0.716
    ],
    "elo": 1590.9,
    "games": 158,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.646
   },
   {
    "axis": "safety",
    "ci": [
     0.267,
     0.811
    ],
    "elo": 1545.3,
    "games": 9,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.556
   },
   {
    "axis": "safety",
    "ci": [
     0.089,
     0.532
    ],
    "elo": 1439.3,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.25
   },
   {
    "axis": "safety",
    "ci": [
     0.202,
     0.356
    ],
    "elo": 1414.7,
    "games": 125,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.272
   },
   {
    "axis": "safety",
    "ci": [
     0.225,
     0.36
    ],
    "elo": 1373.8,
    "games": 170,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.288
   },
   {
    "axis": "safety",
    "ci": [
     0.214,
     0.376
    ],
    "elo": 1281.6,
    "games": 118,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.288
   },
   {
    "axis": "safety",
    "ci": [
     0.117,
     0.224
    ],
    "elo": 1236.1,
    "games": 183,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.164
   }
  ],
  "slot15": [
   {
    "axis": "slot15",
    "ci": [
     0.454,
     0.883
    ],
    "elo": 1568.3,
    "games": 14,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.714
   },
   {
    "axis": "slot15",
    "ci": [
     0.386,
     0.815
    ],
    "elo": 1554.2,
    "games": 16,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.625
   },
   {
    "axis": "slot15",
    "ci": [
     0.434,
     0.903
    ],
    "elo": 1552.2,
    "games": 11,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.727
   },
   {
    "axis": "slot15",
    "ci": [
     0.25,
     0.842
    ],
    "elo": 1511.0,
    "games": 7,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.571
   },
   {
    "axis": "slot15",
    "ci": [
     0.158,
     0.75
    ],
    "elo": 1477.3,
    "games": 7,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.429
   },
   {
    "axis": "slot15",
    "ci": [
     0.108,
     0.603
    ],
    "elo": 1466.4,
    "games": 10,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.3
   },
   {
    "axis": "slot15",
    "ci": [
     0.121,
     0.646
    ],
    "elo": 1461.7,
    "games": 9,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.333
   },
   {
    "axis": "slot15",
    "ci": [
     0.097,
     0.566
    ],
    "elo": 1443.2,
    "games": 11,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.273
   },
   {
    "axis": "slot15",
    "ci": [
     0.063,
     0.547
    ],
    "elo": 1437.2,
    "games": 9,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.222
   }
  ],
  "sovereignty": [
   {
    "axis": "sovereignty",
    "ci": [
     0.397,
     0.892
    ],
    "elo": 1563.7,
    "games": 10,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.7
   },
   {
    "axis": "sovereignty",
    "ci": [
     0.357,
     0.802
    ],
    "elo": 1537.8,
    "games": 15,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.6
   },
   {
    "axis": "sovereignty",
    "ci": [
     0.355,
     0.823
    ],
    "elo": 1522.3,
    "games": 13,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.615
   },
   {
    "axis": "sovereignty",
    "ci": [
     0.237,
     0.763
    ],
    "elo": 1518.7,
    "games": 10,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "sovereignty",
    "ci": [
     0.254,
     0.746
    ],
    "elo": 1496.0,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "sovereignty",
    "ci": [
     0.262,
     0.69
    ],
    "elo": 1488.1,
    "games": 17,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.471
   },
   {
    "axis": "sovereignty",
    "ci": [
     0.121,
     0.646
    ],
    "elo": 1457.3,
    "games": 9,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.333
   },
   {
    "axis": "sovereignty",
    "ci": [
     0.198,
     0.643
    ],
    "elo": 1450.7,
    "games": 15,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.4
   },
   {
    "axis": "sovereignty",
    "ci": [
     0.138,
     0.609
    ],
    "elo": 1447.8,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.333
   }
  ],
  "swarm": [
   {
    "axis": "swarm",
    "ci": [
     0.386,
     0.815
    ],
    "elo": 1548.8,
    "games": 16,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.625
   },
   {
    "axis": "swarm",
    "ci": [
     0.359,
     0.918
    ],
    "elo": 1542.5,
    "games": 7,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.714
   },
   {
    "axis": "swarm",
    "ci": [
     0.337,
     0.754
    ],
    "elo": 1525.6,
    "games": 18,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.556
   },
   {
    "axis": "swarm",
    "ci": [
     0.237,
     0.763
    ],
    "elo": 1504.4,
    "games": 10,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "swarm",
    "ci": [
     0.254,
     0.746
    ],
    "elo": 1502.0,
    "games": 12,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "swarm",
    "ci": [
     0.268,
     0.732
    ],
    "elo": 1493.7,
    "games": 14,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.5
   },
   {
    "axis": "swarm",
    "ci": [
     0.213,
     0.72
    ],
    "elo": 1480.7,
    "games": 11,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.455
   },
   {
    "axis": "swarm",
    "ci": [
     0.185,
     0.614
    ],
    "elo": 1449.2,
    "games": 16,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.375
   },
   {
    "axis": "swarm",
    "ci": [
     0.127,
     0.576
    ],
    "elo": 1442.3,
    "games": 13,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.308
   }
  ],
  "transparency": [
   {
    "axis": "transparency",
    "ci": [
     0.518,
     0.868
    ],
    "elo": 1604.2,
    "games": 22,
    "model": "qwen2.5:7b",
    "winrate": 0.727
   },
   {
    "axis": "transparency",
    "ci": [
     0.326,
     0.786
    ],
    "elo": 1548.2,
    "games": 14,
    "model": "mistral:7b",
    "winrate": 0.571
   },
   {
    "axis": "transparency",
    "ci": [
     0.387,
     0.767
    ],
    "elo": 1538.1,
    "games": 22,
    "model": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "winrate": 0.591
   },
   {
    "axis": "transparency",
    "ci": [
     0.386,
     0.815
    ],
    "elo": 1535.5,
    "games": 16,
    "model": "council-safe:latest",
    "winrate": 0.625
   },
   {
    "axis": "transparency",
    "ci": [
     0.177,
     0.645
    ],
    "elo": 1471.0,
    "games": 13,
    "model": "muse-glimmer:latest",
    "winrate": 0.385
   },
   {
    "axis": "transparency",
    "ci": [
     0.198,
     0.643
    ],
    "elo": 1464.2,
    "games": 15,
    "model": "qwen3:4b",
    "winrate": 0.4
   },
   {
    "axis": "transparency",
    "ci": [
     0.177,
     0.645
    ],
    "elo": 1461.3,
    "games": 13,
    "model": "qwen2.5-0.5b-cards:latest",
    "winrate": 0.385
   },
   {
    "axis": "transparency",
    "ci": [
     0.185,
     0.614
    ],
    "elo": 1457.8,
    "games": 16,
    "model": "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "winrate": 0.375
   },
   {
    "axis": "transparency",
    "ci": [
     0.173,
     0.587
    ],
    "elo": 1452.5,
    "games": 17,
    "model": "council-oowm:latest",
    "winrate": 0.353
   }
  ]
 },
 "register": "MEASURED (deterministic referee-based); LMArena human-vote is REPORTED context, not our measurement.",
 "schema": "csoai.arena-elo-reference/0.1",
 "signature": {
  "alg": "Ed25519",
  "content_id": "d677c1fb21808d0ee74214e8fdc343f4e498785da7b8bf34e0fce71bb3a9f358",
  "note": "Ed25519 over canonical content_id. Verify: recompute canonical (excluding signature), sha256=content_id, ed25519(content_id)==sig using PUBKEY.",
  "pubkey": "j5oAooz8duNgKf6AXz5CGVj019QsTxFIZZGKEAExORI=",
  "sig": "k3cehVb46rB50XZQsw/pN6H/yaAdZiB/xBwHQ25c61z0BS1wQZLAbGFyJ3XnI9bbcFDJWlLbkr1nOPys4iQdCA=="
 }
}