{
 "schema": "csoai.gspc-living/0.1",
 "kind": "board_living",
 "updated": "2026-08-18T03:22:16Z",
 "signed": true,
 "verification_state": "UNVERIFIABLE",
 "verifiable": false,
 "signer_anchored": false,
 "signer": "8f9a00a28cfc76e36029fe805f3e421958f4d7d42c4f114865918a1001313912",
 "signature": "53aa09fa39bbc160c804eee64eb15a847d0fc1b9478ba75de3cd055aa7448bea21962760cb1cd15cea38369439856639ddb52fb44ef1aeddda3663f9ea00440e",
 "sig_input": "sha256(canonical board minus signature fields, sort_keys) — AS PUBLISHED WHEN SIGNED, AND NOT REPRODUCIBLE. This string is not a sufficient preimage rule: it does not say which fields count as signature fields, whether the signature is over the digest bytes, the digest hex or the raw canonical bytes, or how non-ASCII is encoded.",
 "source": "board_living.json (csoai.gspc-living/0.1, boards-v2 + gold-run-3090)",
 "axes": {
  "governance": {
   "status": "MEASURED",
   "accuracy": 0.7,
   "n": 237,
   "leader": "council-embodiment-v3-light (council specialist)",
   "separation": "SEPARATED",
   "interval": [
    0.639,
    0.755
   ]
  },
  "safety": {
   "status": "MEASURED",
   "accuracy": 0.944,
   "n": 36,
   "leader": "gemma3:12b (base model)",
   "separation": "TIE",
   "interval": [
    0.819,
    0.985
   ]
  },
  "provenance": {
   "status": "MEASURED",
   "accuracy": 0.781,
   "n": 32,
   "leader": "council-aesthetics-v3-light (council specialist)",
   "separation": "TIE",
   "interval": [
    0.612,
    0.89
   ]
  },
  "continuity": {
   "status": "MEASURED",
   "accuracy": 0.606,
   "n": 33,
   "leader": "council-destruction-v3-light (council specialist)",
   "separation": "TIE",
   "interval": [
    0.437,
    0.753
   ]
  },
  "conformance": {
   "status": "MEASURED",
   "accuracy": 0.743,
   "n": 35,
   "leader": "council-preservation-v3-light (council specialist)",
   "separation": "TIE",
   "interval": [
    0.579,
    0.858
   ]
  },
  "openness": {
   "status": "MEASURED",
   "accuracy": 0.875,
   "n": 32,
   "leader": "council-preservation-v3-light (council specialist)",
   "separation": "TIE",
   "interval": [
    0.719,
    0.95
   ]
  },
  "machinery-conformity": {
   "status": "MEASURED",
   "accuracy": 0.545,
   "n": 33,
   "leader": "llama3.2:3b (base model)",
   "separation": "TIE",
   "interval": [
    0.38,
    0.702
   ]
  },
  "care": {
   "status": "MEASURED",
   "accuracy": 0.535,
   "n": 199,
   "leader": "council-ethics-v3-light (council specialist)",
   "separation": "SEPARATED",
   "interval": [
    0.466,
    0.603
   ]
  },
  "cross-reality": {
   "status": "MEASURED",
   "accuracy": 0.812,
   "n": 32,
   "leader": "mistral:7b (base model)",
   "separation": "TIE",
   "interval": [
    0.647,
    0.911
   ]
  },
  "detector-interop": {
   "status": "MEASURED",
   "accuracy": 0.879,
   "n": 33,
   "leader": "deepseek-r1:8b (base model)",
   "separation": "TIE",
   "interval": [
    0.727,
    0.952
   ]
  },
  "art5-safeguard": {
   "status": "MEASURED",
   "accuracy": 0.972,
   "n": 36,
   "leader": "council-relationality-v3-light (council specialist)",
   "separation": "TIE",
   "interval": [
    0.858,
    0.995
   ]
  },
  "swarm": {
   "status": "MEASURED",
   "accuracy": 0.384,
   "n": 37,
   "leader": "qwen2.5:7b (base model)",
   "separation": "SEPARATED",
   "interval": null
  },
  "affect": {
   "status": "MEASURED",
   "accuracy": 0.878,
   "n": 41,
   "leader": "council-preservation-v3-light (council specialist)",
   "separation": "SEPARATED",
   "interval": [
    0.745,
    0.947
   ]
  },
  "jail": {
   "status": "MEASURED",
   "accuracy": 0.5915,
   "n": 71,
   "leader": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct (base model)",
   "separation": "TIE",
   "interval": [
    0.475,
    0.698
   ],
   "separation_method": "Wilson 95% interval over n=71 items tested against the fleet mean (stat_suite.separated_leaders, McNemar-style Wilson-overlap check)",
   "separation_evidence": {
    "leader": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "leader_acc": 0.5915,
    "wilson95": [
     0.475,
     0.698
    ],
    "fleet_mean": 0.5455,
    "determination": "leader interval contains fleet mean — point-estimate lead is not a measured advantage",
    "determined": "2026-08-25"
   },
   "quotable_models": [
    "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct",
    "council-safe",
    "qwen2.5:7b",
    "mistral:7b",
    "qwen2.5:1.5b",
    "qwen3:4b",
    "council-oowm"
   ],
   "quotable_note": "7 models x >=30 usable gold-bank items (68-71 each); per-model n recorded in gspc-measurement.json"
  }
 },
 "totals": {
  "axes": 14,
  "measured_axes": 14,
  "quotable_axes": 14,
  "public_count": "14 measured of 14 quotable",
  "license": "CC-BY-4.0",
  "license_note": "Board data is CC-BY-4.0 (attribute: Council of AI, CSOAI Ltd 16939677, councilof.ai). Our own valve-2 bench-card flagged the payload's missing licence field — fixed same day.",
  "items": 887,
  "separated_leads": 4,
  "ties": 10,
  "untested_separations": 0,
  "mean_macro_f1": 0.7528,
  "mean_accuracy": 0.7318,
  "mean_fleet_mean": 0.5443,
  "mean_harm": 0.4877,
  "mean_unparsed_rate": 0.0813,
  "mean_note": "Means are over MEASURED axes that carry the field. mean_accuracy averages the per-axis LEADERS; mean_fleet_mean averages each axis's measured fleet — the difference is selection, not skill. mean_harm is the severity-weighted failure mass the mean accuracy hides; it exists only for the 13 board-v2 axes."
 },
 "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.21991104",
 "packaged_at": "2026-08-24T07:58:34.454956+00:00",
 "note": "Axes snapshot from live /api/gspc at package time. Signature fields are the SITTING-1 living_stamp already published on /api/gspc.",
 "live_stamp": "GET /api/gspc measured_on.living_stamp is re-signed at the edge under did:web:csoai.org#board-attestation-1 (schema csoai.gspc-living/0.2). THIS FILE keeps the historical 2026-08-18 stamp, which stays UNVERIFIABLE. Do not treat this file as the live stamp.",
 "unverifiable_note": "DO NOT TREAT THIS AS A VALID ATTESTATION. Marked UNVERIFIABLE 2026-08-26. No published bytes reproduce this signature: 58,184 readings were attempted across both published signatures for this stamp, all five published keys, nine candidate payloads, raw/sha256-digest/sha256-hex message forms, both ensure_ascii settings, and every drop-set of up to three fields. Zero verified. Three faults, stated plainly. (1) TWO signatures are published for one stamp: 53aa09fa… here and bd199fd3… in /api/gspc measured_on.living_stamp, same signer, same `updated`; at most one can be over the bytes the other is over. (2) The signer 8f9a00a2… is in NONE of the four verification methods in https://csoai.org/.well-known/did.json, so it is not anchored and a reproducing preimage would still only prove self-consistency. (3) `note` below states that the axes in this file were re-snapshotted from the live board at package time (2026-08-24) while the signature is dated 2026-08-18 — so the signed bytes are not these bytes. Nothing here is asserted to be invalid; it is asserted to be UNCHECKABLE, which for a relying party is the same outcome. This file is kept published rather than withdrawn so the failure is on the record. To close it: anchor the signer in did.json, publish the exact preimage, and publish ONE signature. Owner-gated. See /api/corrections C-2026-0826-08.",
 "preimage_exclusions": [
  "signature",
  "signer",
  "signed",
  "sig_input",
  "verification_state",
  "verifiable",
  "signer_anchored",
  "unverifiable_note",
  "preimage_exclusions",
  "marked_unverifiable_on"
 ],
 "marked_unverifiable_on": "2026-08-26",
 "verify_these_instead": {
  "cards": "/signed/cards/<id>.json under did:web:csoai.org#card-attestation-1 — 150/150 verify; see /signed/HOW-TO-VERIFY.md",
  "board": "site_attestation on GET /api/gspc under did:web:csoai.org#board-attestation-1 — verifies; see its sig_input for the exact encoding",
  "frozen_board": "/signed/gspc-board.signed.json — verifies via scripts/gspc-board-verify.mjs"
 }
}